Today's Viewpoint: A MarshBerry Publication

Insurance Industry Compensation Trends: The Value of Service Staff

There’s a lot of data and research around compensation for producers, but what about the rest of your staff? What incentives and rewards do you have in place for other critical positions such as Account Executives and Account Managers?

When it comes to total rewards for your staff, aligning with insurance industry compensation trends can make a big difference. Your firm’s compensation cost is likely the most significant expense, but it can also be the expense that most needs adjustments. Inconsistencies across roles can leave some employees feeling less valued. A thorough approach to compensation across positions leads to endless benefits.

The importance of a strong compensation strategy

Strong compensation models give your firm a competitive edge in retaining and attracting top talent. A well-designed total rewards package can help you make long-term decisions related to salary, benefits packages, or budget planning.

Proper compensation contributes to the overall success of your business. Top-level salaries and bonuses make your staff feel valued, motivating them to contribute their best work. Workers go above and beyond to serve customers when company morale increases, increasing client retention.

Compensating service staff

Many firms have a strong compensation structure for producers based on individual performance, but few have a compensation structure based on service staff performance.

A direct relationship exists between being a top-performing firm and offering competitive pay for service personnel. This chart illustrates the relationship between service staff payroll and organic growth rates. Top-performing firms spend 33% more per employee; their average productivity is 80% higher than the lowest 25% group.

Compensation trends for insurance employees

Think beyond the commission model

Top-performing firms look for alternative ways to structure compensation plans for service personnel. Employees desire a work environment with a work-life balance, including remote work options and flexible scheduling. The primary motivator for getting the best results from an employee isn’t always monetary. Providing generous paid time off policies, including vacation days, holidays, and personal leave, allows employees to recharge and rejuvenate. Other team members may be motivated by career development. Sponsoring them to achieve a specific designation or tuition reimbursement can boost current staff and attract others to your firm. Creating a thriving culture where people can meet/exceed personal goals is a surefire way to become a preferred employer.  

Total rewards packages for service staff in the insurance industry encompass a broad range of benefits and incentives designed to attract and retain talented individuals. These packages prioritize competitive compensation, health and wellness benefits, work-life balance, career development opportunities, and financial security. Insurance agencies create an engaging and supportive work environment that values their employees’ contributions and well-being by providing comprehensive rewards.


MarshBerry’s 2023 Agency & Brokerage Compensation Review: Available for Purchase

MarshBerry’s 2023 Insurance Agency & Brokerage Compensation Review  explores the prevalent compensation trends concerning insurance agents and brokers.  This one-of-a-kind report comprehensively examines current compensation data for 31 roles commonly found across insurance agents and brokers. The report offers insight into Executive & Management Compensation, Production, Service Staff, and Support Staff. Learn more and purchase here.

Contact Eric Kuhen
If you have questions about Today's ViewPoint, or would like to learn more about how MarshBerry can help your firm determine its path forward, please email or call Eric Kuhen, Vice President, at 440.637.8118.

MarshBerry is a global leader in investment banking and consulting services, specializing in the insurance brokerage and wealth management sectors. If your firm seeks expert advisory guidance to refine your business strategies, drive sustainable growth, or facilitate a sale, MarshBerry is the ideal partner to support you in making these critical business decisions. Collaborating with a trusted advisor who deeply understands your business and the industry can help you maximize value at every stage of ownership.